The saying "Having no offspring is the greatest tragedy" cannot rouse a baby's cry—encouraging childbirth requires first ensuring a stable home.

The Legislative Council recently discussed population trends, with some reiterating the old saying "having no offspring is a major life loss," and others attributing the declining birth rate to rising "individualism." It's as if simply repeating family responsibilities and giving ethics lectures will magically boost the birth rate. This diagnosis oversimplifies the problem. Preaching won't increase living space, fill childcare slots, or eliminate the career opportunities sacrificed by parents caring for children. If population policy only aims to change young people's attitudes, it's tantamount to handing the systemic problems back to families. Is it that Hong Kong's youth don't want to start families, or is it that the city simply can't provide the conditions that make them feel secure enough to settle down?

The real crisis is when wishes are not fulfilled.

The United Nations Population Fund's "World Population Situation Report 2025" warns that population issues cannot be viewed solely by birth rates, but also by whether citizens can achieve their ideal family size. The survey, covering 14 countries, found that nearly 20% of adults of childbearing age do not expect to have their ideal number of children, with economic constraints being the primary hurdle. Hong Kong has also been facing similar warnings. A 2018 survey by the Hong Kong Federation of Youth Groups found that respondents' ideal number of children was an average of 1.84, while the actual expected number was only 1.41, reflecting that the phenomenon of "wanting to have children but not being able to" is not new. A rights-based population policy does not push reproduction back into the private sphere, but rather shifts the focus from requiring citizens to achieve population targets to having the government remove institutional barriers.

October 5th is World Habitat Day, themed "Adequate Housing for All." The United Nations points out that adequate housing is based on dignity, security, and opportunity, and goes beyond just four walls. Adequate housing means affordable rent, sufficient space, a location that doesn't lengthen commutes, and access to basic services nearby. Families need four layers of security: time, services, housing, and community, and these four are interconnected. Living far away means longer commutes; childcare time doesn't align with working hours, forcing parents to reduce their workload; decreased income makes improving housing even more distant. Therefore, housing is more than just a dwelling; it's a family infrastructure comprised of caregiving time, public services, and community support.

A new mother recently shared on social media that she and her husband had poured all their savings into a one-bedroom apartment. After their baby was born, the crib, stroller, and daily necessities quickly filled the space. Her concern wasn't just about the current cramped conditions, but about where her child would sleep and study as they grew up. Whether or not to have another child is often not a value debate. The question itself is small, yet weighty: will there be room for another bed in the house? Housing is only one end of the constraint; the other is caregiving. Most childcare centers operate until 6 pm on weekdays, with only some extending their hours. Parents working shifts or in other areas may not be able to pick up their children in time. Families are forced to rely on grandparents, domestic helpers, or have one parent reduce their workload. This childcare shortage translates into income loss, which in turn weakens the ability to improve housing conditions.

The policy is not about creating new problems, but about sharing the burden.

International experience offers no magic bullet for increasing birth rates, but it does provide systems for sharing the costs. Swedish parents receive 480 days of childcare allowance, with each parent having 90 non-transferable days. The "use it or lose it" principle isn't just a pretty slogan; it encourages fathers to leave their desks and be present in the caregiving field, preventing the burden of professional sacrifices from falling entirely on mothers. Denmark stipulates that children of legal residents are entitled to day care from age 26 until school enrollment. What Hong Kong should learn from isn't the welfare figures, but the attitude towards governance. The government shouldn't just talk about increasing quotas, but also be responsible for ensuring families actually receive services. Policy effectiveness shouldn't be judged solely by how many more children are born, but also by how many families are no longer forced to give up.

In recent years, mainland China has gradually incorporated childcare from a private family matter into a public service. Through "integrated childcare and early childhood education," it encourages qualified kindergartens to open toddler classes for two- to three-year-olds and utilizes community spaces and vacant school buildings to develop full-day, half-day, hourly, and temporary childcare services, allowing families to access these services within their local communities. Shenzhen has already established management standards for kindergarten toddler classes and built community childcare centers and a "15-minute childcare service circle." This also echoes its concept of "viewing the city from a one-meter height," where planners can only see the problems children and caregivers face—such as steps, pedestrian safety, shade, and rest areas—by crouching down to their level. Whether a city is livable depends not only on the height of its buildings but also on whether children can move around safely and whether caregivers can feel at ease in their daily lives.

The new area needs planning, and the old area needs renovation.

Hong Kong is not entirely inactive; the newborn baby incentive, priority housing allocation, and additional places in childcare centers can alleviate some of the pressure. The problem is that policies operate piecemeal, failing to connect housing, childcare, job security, and community support into a unified network. The government should integrate policies through a "family-community interconnection" approach and implement family development impact assessments. Before housing, planning, transportation, and labor policies are introduced, their impact on family formation, care costs, and parental employment must be clearly explained, and high-level coordination across departments is crucial for implementation.

The Northern Metropolitan Area should take the lead in establishing standards for family-friendly communities, listing childcare for children aged 0-3, maternal and infant health, children's play areas, and family support as essential pre-occupancy amenities, not post-occupancy add-ons. Planning should also incorporate the Housing Authority's "Well-being Design" guidelines, addressing stroller access, shaded seating, and intergenerational rest areas. These standards must be written into land leases and acceptance conditions. Otherwise, even the best blueprints will remain merely on paper.

Beyond new developments, old villages also need renewal. The renovation of public spaces in Ping Shek Village, including the addition of seating, greenery, and activity facilities, demonstrates that "micro-renewal" can facilitate outings for caregivers with young children, allowing the elderly and children to share a space. The government should regularly review community standards and adjust facilities according to the number of young children and their usage, ensuring that renovations are not one-off projects but rather systematically benefit developed communities.

A bed is also a source of confidence.

A decline in kindergarten enrollment does not necessarily signify a school closure crisis; it could also be an opportunity for childcare transformation. The government could inventory vacant classrooms, subsidize the renovation of suitable school buildings, train staff, and establish childcare classes for two- to three-year-olds. Community service centers could also incorporate parent support, childcare information, and service referrals. Where conditions are ripe, regulated short-term childcare could be piloted, serving as family service hubs. Given the lack of time for families, the government could study father-only, non-transferable parental leave in addition to existing maternity and paternity leave, and assist SMEs in sharing some of the costs. Only by enabling fathers to actually take on more caregiving time can we prevent the childcare responsibility from continuing to concentrate on mothers, ultimately resulting in women bearing the costs through reduced income, hindered career advancement, and narrowed employment opportunities.

Low birth rates are a lagging indicator of urban confidence. Whether young people dare to start families reflects whether they believe Hong Kong can shoulder the burden of housing, employment, and caregiving for the next 20 years. Rights-based policies do not mean clinging to the idea that "having no offspring is the greatest misfortune," nor do they mean shifting the problem to "individualism." They require cities to provide fourfold protection: time, services, housing, and community. A home should not only accommodate a crib but also allow for a family's aspirations for the future. Population policy should aim to enable citizens to choose family life with the means, support, and dignity.

[Hong Kong 01]: https://www.hk01.com/article/60401872?utm_source=01articlecopy&utm_medium=referral